Saw this rack for a XRL.

Looks too small to me, and it raises turn signals, not good.

I like the xrs only rack!

That rack is made of hollow tube steel. I E-mailed the guy that makes it and he confirmed that. There is another on E-bay that is made out of solid round tube, I bought that one and it's strong and light, I can pick up the back end of the bike and move it in the garage.

Square steel tubing is much stronger than solid round steel. There is much more of a surface which in turn is able to spread weight and force over a much larger area.:mad: Also this rack has 5 mounting points, most others have 3.

Steel rack + paint = junk. TOO SMALL and will be scuffed and scratched , turn signal get kicked every time you get on or off. So what will it pack? a coffee cup!

Steel rack + paint = junk. TOO SMALL and will be scuffed and scratched , turn signal get kicked every time you get on or off. So what will it pack? a coffee cup!

What do you want to carry with you? A Foot locker?

Square steel tubing is much stronger than solid round steel. There is much more of a surface which in turn is able to spread weight and force over a much larger area.:mad: Also this rack has 5 mounting points, most others have 3.

Really then I wonder why......

What do you want to carry with you? A Foot locker?

You would say this? You cant have it both way's either it's big enough or it's not.

:mad:

Square steel tubing is much stronger than solid round steel. There is much more of a surface which in turn is able to spread weight and force over a much larger area.:mad: Also this rack has 5 mounting points, most others have 3.

Now as for this remark. Hollow is stronger then solid? Really, I asked the one of the Engineers at Warn Industries, you know that place that makes winches, ATV bumpers, Brush guards, wenches, Bumpers, and all sorts of other off road stuff about this, and he laughed out loud! :mad: So the question on everyones mind is this.. Are you getting any money this? Or are you just trying to mislead everyone on a power trip? Or is there some other reason why you would flip flop so much? Inquiring mind want to know! :mad:

Yeah, I think the guy is making the racks and selling them on ebay, the way he talks about them and all, things not big enough to put a milk crate on, which by the way is the best thing to haul stuff in if your running errands.:mad:

The best rack out there by far is the xrs only rack, its light, strong and looks damn cool.:mad:

Yeah, I think the guy is making the racks and selling them on ebay, the way he talks about them and all, things not big enough to put a milk crate on, which by the way is the best thing to haul stuff in if your running errands.:mad:

The best rack out there by far is the xrs only rack, its light, strong and looks damn cool.:mad:[/quote

If you look it's a Happy Trails Rack and the last time I checked I didn't own the company.:mad:

I have the Happy Trails rack like this one on my L. Works fine. I like the 5 mounts, really solid. It was a bit fiddly to mount the first time. I think one of the big reasons I liked it over the XR's Only/Promoto rack is you keep the tool bag, although I did turn my toolbag around so I could get to the zipper easier. I haven't noticed an issue with the relocated blinkers. I bolted a Givi base plate to it with expands the rack area and now I can snap any of the GIVI cases I have for my street bike to it. I have a 52L trunk that I can put my laptop and workout bag in no problem for riding to work. I throw all my gear in it then once I get there so I don't have to carry it in to the office.

Downside is the rack sits higher than others though and I've noticed it'll smack me in the butt sometimes in whoops.

Kelleyseiller, so why are you trying to convince poeple that tubular steel is stronger/better than solid? why are you trying to get poeple to buy a rack that is not big enough to actually pack anything bigger than a six pack?

Why? Are you really convinced this is the best rack for everyone?

:mad: :mad: :mad::worthy::ride::banana:

Look its a six pack, but I dont think it will fit on my rack!!!

Kelleyseiller, so why are you trying to convince poeple that tubular steel is stronger/better than solid? why are you trying to get poeple to buy a rack that is not big enough to actually pack anything bigger than a six pack?

Why? Are you really convinced this is the best rack for everyone?

:mad: :mad: :mad::worthy::ride::banana:

Look its a six pack, but I dont think it will fit on my rack!!!

From an engineering standpoint square tubing is stonger than solid steel of the same diameter just as steel I-beam is stronger than a solid steel beam. That is why they build skyscrapers with it and not solid steel beams.

Why do you feel that I am trying to convince everyone of anything, I just put it out there because it was a really good deal on that particular rack. Maybe if you pull your redneck head out of your a$$ you would see that.

Hail to almighty Rebelventurer O King of Thumpertalk!

Thank you Mr. seiller bout time I got a little respect. Hey, sorry I thought you were trying to brainwash everyone into being happy trails rack owners. sorry for any misappropriated words, I guess as long as you have a place to put what you need its good enough! :mad:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now