Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
yam314

Scared to buy another YZ450 !

39 posts in this topic

I have owned a 98 YZ400 (that ate 3'rd gear),a 2004 WR400 (good bike), a 2007 YZ450 (broke a crank),

a 2008 YZ450, and now a 2010 YZ450 that just ate a 5'th gear. I bought another motor that also had a broken 5'th gear. Now a friend has a 2011 YZ450 that has been completely rebuilt because it broke a 5'th gear. Seems to be a pattern! I love the bike, but tearing down transmissions is no fun. I would like to buy another YZF, but have serious doubts about the reliability. Anyone else having 5'th gear problems?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Didn't you already make this exact thread? http://www.thumpertalk.com/topic/1074396-10-11-broken-4th-gear-problems-is-this-common/

 

I have a 2010 YZ450F that had a chunk missing off of a tooth at 165 hours of hard A class mx racing. It didn't act funny at all, I found it while replacing the crank during regular preventative maintenance (nothing was wrong with the crank, just changing it for piece of mind). No problem since, nor have any of my previous YZ450's had any issues like that.

 

Why would you buy a whole motor if you just needed one gear in the tranny? The gears are not that expensive individually.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wasn't the previous complaint about 4th gear? The only recurring tranny issues I have ever heard from a YZ was the 3rd gear issue with the 250 2ts. Never heard of anyone having any issues with any other bikes. This smells like a troll and I guess I am just dumb enough to respond :/

 

Well, maybe not a troll, but odd none the less.

Edited by swaldrop

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No, I'm not trolling. It's that I am trying to decide this week whether to buy another 2011 450 or not, fearing that the same problem might happen again, and i was just trying to get more replies about this issue happening with other '10 thru '13 YZ450 owners. It is just very odd, that I have seen problems with 3 different motors breaking this same gear in one week.I first posted that it was 4'th gear, but was later told that it was my 5'th gear (I cannot edit the title of the post).

 

 I am not a transmission expert, and my plan was to purchase a complete engine, and part out my old engine. As you can tell, this thing has me very frustrated, and I am thinking of going Honda , and just wanted to get opinions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hope its not an issue. Just bought an 06 a few weeks ago after a lot of research. I hadnt heard of 450s having bad 5th gears. Now my dr650 blew 3rd on the interstate doing 85 mph. But there are occurrences of this happening, just not very often. Guess I was the lucky one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I first posted that it was 4'th gear, but was later told that it was my 5'th gear (I cannot edit the title of the post).

 

Yeah, my bad. Just seemed fishy with the multiple posts, different details, etc.

Regardless, either you are just really unlucky, or there are a ton of us riding around with chipped gears in the transmission. Seems pretty odd that you would happen across so of them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It is just that I have had several big bore YZF's but here in the past week, 3 bikes with 3 different riders all have the same exact problem ! Yeah, I have been racing long enough to know that stuff will break (since 1976), but it really does appear that Yamaha may have a problem with this particular engine blowing 5'th gear. Just wanting to know if maybe the replacement gear is made differently than the previous gear.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And too, I probably did not even realize that the gear was boken, until the little part lodged in my idler gear , and it in turn, tore up a bunch of 

other  gears. There are many damaged parts inside.

Edited by yam314

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

buy 2003-2005 and never have to worry about 5th gear breaking again. :rolleyes:

 

Sry,had to do it.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As I said, I HAVE owned a 2004, 2007 & a 2008 YZ450, and have not had any issue with them.(well my '04 was a WR)

It is the 2010-2013 bikes I am talking about. I think there is some sort of a problem with the 5'th gear !

Edited by yam314

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sometimes change is good. If you have a good local dealer I'd take a look at 2012-newer KX450. Great bike and fantastic reliability.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been such a Yamaha guy since 1976. It's tough to give it up! Here are the Yamahas I have owned:

 

1975 MX400

1977 YZ400

1978 YZ400

1978 Husky 390 (blew up that tranny)

1980 YZ465 (what a beast !)

1984 IT490

1989 YZ250

1990 YZ250

1994 WR250

1998 WR400f

2004 WR450

2007 YZ450f

2008 YZ450f

2010 YZ450f

Edited by yam314

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Similar Content

    • By MotocrossTime
      So the first look Yamaha YZ450F/YZ250F. I dont see a big update at here. 
      YAMAHA FACTORY RACING TEAM “factory machine developed with an eye to acquiring championships in all Japan Nationals and acquisition of advanced technology. For metal spring front forks and intake / exhaust system layout, we follow the market YZ, adopt electric starter etc, and incorporate factory exclusive parts in each part.
      YZ450FM


      YZ250FM

      “YAMAHA FACTORY RACING TEAM” will compete in IA 1 and IA 2. The team is organized by professionals from various fields centered on Yamaha engineers. With a strong team structure I will fight the mission to acquire IA 1, double title of IA 2, and advanced technology aimed at feedback to commercial vehicles.
      Rider participates in IA 1, Hirata Yu who is one of the domestic top riders and is a part of the champion candidate. The 2016 season returned for the first time in a season from the injury of the year before last, the ranking became the fifth place, but it is a presence that does not feel blank and it exerts its presence. This season we aim for the challenge of the wish of the factory machine “YZ 450 FM”.
      It is Yusuke Watanabe who drives “YZ 250 FM” at IA 2. Last season, I participated in a youth team that aims to train young people, jumped up from 6th place in ranking to 3rd place in 2015, achieved great growth as the team concept, and this year was promoted to a factory rider. For the 2017 season, we are training to Doug Dubac who flew off to America and played an active role in AMA, and this season we aim to win the IA 2 championship.
      More at : MOTOCROSSTIME

    • By Perri07
      I have a 2006 yz250. It was fully rebuilt top to bottom last winter before racing started
      rode all year and it was fine
      the problem I am having after winter start up is
      starts no problem, run decent, when I turn the throttle smoke and. Lack oil spray out of the silencer like if I put a glove on there's a nice layer of oil
       
      also the part of the carb that comes out of the tps and sits on the throttle slide. To me seems loose as in I can lift it to a point and it doesn't spring back. Is it suppose to stay tight to the top of the slide 
      it feels like it doesn't any force down till about 3/4 throttle when I hold it up with my finger 
       
      also when I lean my bike over the idle picks up a lot
       
       
    • By cosmoKenney
      2009 Husky WR 300.
      New top and bottom end.
      New brake pads and they were just bled. 
      Hyde skid plate.
      FMF Gnarly pipe and FMF Q-Stealth silencer.
      JD Jet kit.
      Comes with extra cylinder, head and piston. 
      Comes with lighter springs for the suspension.
      Pulls like a mule.
      This is an awesome trail bike. If you ride Georgetown, Foresthill, Elkins Flat or Chalk Bluff this bike will not let you down.
       
    • By Steve Sutton
      Apologies for the long post, but I’m including as much info as possible.
      I have a 2-Stroke Yamaha TDR250 1KT, same motor as the TZR250 apparently.
      I just completed a top-end rebuild. I only replaced the left piston as the right one look good. Probably should have replaced both, but anyway…
      My problem is the right cylinder/exhaust gets very hot very quickly and smokes a lot. The exhaust is hot only after 30 seconds of idling. The left remains room temperature and does not smoke.
      I don’t want to ride it too much in case it causes irreparable damage. But when I did try to ride her, I can only get a few hundred meters before she cuts out. I have to start again and can not get into 2nd gear before it stalls again. I’d have to limp home at a bicycle’s pace as anything above idle revs kills the engine.
      Not sure if the poor running is related to the hot exhaust, or another problem entirely.
      I’ve done the following troubleshooting:
      - swapped around plugs – no difference
      - swapped around plug leads – no difference
      - swapped around Carburetors (but not the Jet Needles) – This then made the left cylinder smoke and the right smoked a little, but not as much as previously. The carbs are back on their original sides as they are specifically left and right.
      - sprayed carb cleaner onto the carb boots to test for air leaks and that had no effect.
      - Raised the Jet Needle in the right carb for a richer mixture – It appears to smoke less (could be my imagination), but it still gets hot quickly.
      - Checked the plugs again and the troublesome cylinder’s plug looks to be running very rich (all dirty), so I lowered the needle this time for a leaner mixture. Still no difference.
      I removed the exhaust and wiped my finger in the cylinder’s exhaust port. Looks like black paint!
      Has anyone ever experienced this and what was the solution?
    • By nissan_twinturbo
      just curious if anyone has ridden both the new and last gen yz450 and how different they REALLY are. i can read reviews all day but theyre all from professional mx racers that probably pick up on little things id never notice. selling my ktm, pretty set on getting me a new yz, my price range is around 4k so that puts me in the range of buying a 2010-2013 yz450. however im being told from a few guys who ride these that i really need to save and spring for a 2014+, the cheapest 2014 i could find was $5000. are the 14's really that much better? should i save and go for one of those? My main actual question is with that same money could i make a 2013 the same or even better? What ever one i decide on ill probably do the same to either for aftermaket parts, exhaust , tuner, fly wheel weight and a lowering link in the rear. Ive ridden a 2015, which is what sold me on one, i loved it! i just dont wanna be disappointed if i get the early gen. either way will be better around the track then my ktm exc! lol, but man that electric start is soo nice