This thread has gotten way off topic . . .
I am currently suing Ford under the lemon law due to transmission issues with my F-150. If the tranny worked properly I'd be thrilled with this truck.
I ordered from the factory with the 5.0 V-8 and 3.77 rear end. While a little soft on low end torque, the engine flies once revved up. Cruising down the highway at 60mph with no load, no head wind or tail wind and I get 22 mpg. That is the same I got in my 2006 Frontier. That is AWESOME mileage from a 5,500 pound truck with a 360 hp/380 ft lb V-8.
But since I am suing Ford I am looking at either a Ram or Tundra. I like the looks of the GM but the 5.3 is just too underpowered for me. The 5.0 in my F-150 destroys that engine in hp and torque and with the aforementioned mileage, believe it will beat or at least tie a GM 5.3. Before ordering my F-150 I drove a Ram and a Tundra. My only gripe with the Tundra at the time was the lack of a bench seat. I like a split bench in a full size truck and that killed the Tundra for me. Also, I think the Tundra is way behind GM, Ford and Ram for interior design layout.
I suspect my suit will be resolved in the next two weeks and I'll trade my F-150 in. If Ford gives me a good enough deal I may chance a 2nd F-150. If I can get one that shifts properly I'll be happy for many years. OTOH, fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me. So maybe I should get something else.
The Tundra has an awesome drive train but a mediocre interior and questionable fuel economy. I'd really like to be able to hit 20 mpg cruising empty at 60mph. On the up side the limited option packages make it easy to get the exact truck I want. Of course that won't include a bench seat but I can probably get used to that. The MSRP would be around $37k but Toyota has the lowest incentives right now.
A Ford would sticker about 38k but with $5,500 in incentives, would be much cheaper. Of course I have already been burned once and an now gun shy. In addition, I ordered my F-150 XLT to get it exactly the way I want it. I can't find another truck like it and would likely have to get one with an MSRP of 40k to 41k to get at least the options I want. That brings it closer to the Toyota price wise.
The new 2013 Ram is less interesting to me than many other buyers. Given my issues with the Ford 6R80 Transmission, I am not anxious to beta test the new eight speed in the Ram. Also, first gear in that new eight speed is like 4.5:1. My F-150 has a first gear at 4.2:1 and that is already useless for me. The current 5/6 speed 645RFE in the Ram appears to be pretty solid so a good deal on a 2012 Ram is very tempting. To me it is easily the best looking truck and has an interior on par with Ford and way above the Tundra. Also, I have heard if you drive the Ram in the same manner as I drive my F-150, you can get 22 mpg in cylinder-deativation mode. I am NOT buying a truck for mileage but if brand A can get 22 on the highway but brand B (Tundra) can only get 18, that is a pretty big difference.
I have heard the new Silverado will debut late Summer. I would speculate it will be an all new vehicle with a much improved 5.3 or new engine altogether. So I won't buy the current generation GM and would rather wait a year or two to get the bugs worked out of the current model.
Finally, most people don't have the issues with the Ford 6 speed like I do and yet I got a bad one. Given how highly rated Ford is it goes to show you can have issues with any top rated vehicle. Based on that I no longer worry about consumer reports and other "objective" measurements of predicted reliability. For as much money as a new truck costs, get the one you want and take care of it. If you get a good one and take care of it, it should last many years.
NC
Edited by NumberCruncher, 21 April 2012 - 07:14 PM.