woodsryder said:
Let's talk about strength here. I love stainless steel but there's no need to use 8mm thick just because the aluminum ones were. If you're using a 300 alloy, I believe it actually has a slightly lower yield strength than cheap hot rolled steel,.. which is still three times more than the aluminum tabs you are replacing. 4mm SS would be overkill and you could probably get by with 3mm if was a better grade of steel. In english, 1/8 thick should work in 4130 steel, 3/16 in low carbon cold rolled or even hot rolled steel. I found some 1/4 thick hot rolled strip at Home Depot that was 1 1/2 wide so I'll use that to avoid a lot of cutting, I would have used 3/16 but they had none.
Now on to the bolts,.. Suzuki chose one grade 8.8, 10 mm bolt for the pivot and that was sized for an overweight rider with a passenger and gear over the biggest bump they could imagine,.. with a big safety margin. You might think we need to at least match that strength with our 4 new bolts but we dont. Their clevis bolt handles all the compression loads but our bolts won't need to. The side plates should butt squarely up against the lower spring retainer with no gap. If this is done, our new bolts won't see any compression loads at all!
There are no side loads either, so all that's left is extension. The worst case here would be a big jump with a blown out shock having no rebound damping. This would allow the shock to extend and slam the internal rebound shock stopping the 100 lbs or so of wheel and swingarm. This is a very small number, and even smaller if the shock has rebound damping to cushion the action. Four good 6 mm bolts in double shear could lift your car off the ground, we only need to stop a 100 lb or so. We could obviously use something smaller.
There seems to be room for three, 1/4 or 6mm bolts easily, but the fourth one may be a tight squeeze next to the adjuster? I'm thinking maybe two 1/4 grade 8 bolts in diagonal corners would do the job, but might as well use three since they fit easily. Another option might be to use four 5mm bolts.
That's my story and I'm sticking with it,.. I should also mention that I am NOT an engineer so proceed at your own risk. The logic above tells me this mod should be stronger than stock. The best alternative method proposed, needs machine work and results in a reduction in bearing area from 20mm to 16mm. while others end up with only 10-12 mm wide caged bearings and one poster even ran without seals !!!!
All your points are well made and valid.
Forgive a humble engineer that knows better but will always be accused of over-engineering.
The fact that I have shitloads of stainless about and I have a mate that loves machining it doesn't help.
We both get a kick out of a piece of stainless that has been whittled into something that looks like it belongs on a Zonda.
What can I say .. Men being kids!
I guess the answer to the age old question "Why?" is " Because I can."
The rest of you take heed of woodsryders comments.
Hopefully the drawings I supplied might be of some use.