Jump to content

  • Follow us:

  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Instagram
  • RSS Feed
  • Google+


Moto Mind
Moto Mind is a technical blog written by Paul Olesen who is a powertrain engineer working in the motorcycle industry. The blog covers a wide variety of topics relating to two and four stroke engine performance, design, and optimization.


Photo
* * * * * 2 votes

Do You Know The Importance of Tightening Techniques?

Posted by Paul Olesen , November 05, 2016 · 4,800 views

Do You Know The Importance of Tightening Techniques?

I hope you’re all enjoying the fall weather. For those of you in northern states, I hope that you’re getting in some end of season riding. This month I want to touch on bolted joints and the importance of adhering to tightening techniques outlined in your model’s service manual.

 

How A Clamped Joint Works
I’m going to discuss the importance of criss-cross patterns, tightening sequences, incremental steps, and joint lubrication but first I want to explain how a bolted joint works. As a bolt is tightened to secure a pair of parts, the bolt will stretch a very small amount. The stretch in the bolt creates tension or preload in the joint which is the force that keeps the joint together. The amount of preload created is dependent on bolt size, bolt material, the torque applied, and the friction between the threads. There are additional variables, however a discussion on bolt engineering would be very long and not all that exciting! As long as you understand the basics for engine building you can begin to appreciate the importance of correctly tightening fasteners.

 

As you are well aware, an engine consists of many parts fastened together. What you may not consider as much is that the majority of these parts are fastened by more than one fastener. This means that how much you tighten/preload one fastener will have an effect on the surrounding fasteners. This interaction between the fasteners begins to shed light on why tightening sequences are so important.

 

The evenness of the preload across the bolts securing a part can affect part life. Warpage can occur in parts which are improperly tightened, ultimately rendering the part useless. A prime example of a part that can warp is a four-stroke cylinder head. If the bolts are unevenly tightened over time, the cylinder head can become permanently distorted. Gasket sealing problems can also occur from improper preloading of bolts across a part. In order for a gasket to seal it must be evenly compressed. If one area of a gasket is highly compressed and tensioned while another area is not, the gasket can easily leak through the low tensioned area. In the case of plain bearing bores, such as the cam cap, uneven preloading may cause the bearing bore to distort. As a result the cam may become difficult to turn. Or if run, the cam bearing bore will wear unevenly and in severe cases the cam could seize.

 

While ensuring bolt preload is even can be a problem there are three tightening techniques that virtually eliminate the issue. If you’ve been building engines for any length of time you’ve probably already been utilizing these techniques. Hopefully now you may have a better understanding of why the service manual instructs you to tighten parts a specific way.

 

Criss-Cross Patterns
Criss-cross patterns are called out when tightening or loosening parts with a simple square pattern or circular bolt pattern. These basic patterns have been around for a very long time and are a proven method for evenly distributing clamping load across a part. Most cylinder heads will utilize this type of clamping pattern.
Posted Image
Tightening Sequences
For more complex bolt patterns, such as those found on cam carriers and crankcases, the manufacturer will usually identify a specific sequence for tightening and loosening the fasteners. This sequence is based on testing and the past experiences of the manufacturer.

 

Posted Image

 

Incremental Steps
Highly torqued bolts, such as those found on the cylinder head, are almost always tightened and loosened in incremental steps. An incremental tightening sequence consists of torquing all the fasteners to a specific torque value, then increasing the torque and tightening again, and finally arriving at the final torque value. This sequence is typically performed in two to three steps.

 

Here’s something important to keep in mind regarding incremental steps! When torquing bolts in steps the change in torque between the steps must be large enough to induce bolt movement. For example if a bolt was torqued to 35Nm at the first step and the second step was 38Nm this would not be enough of a change to make the bolt move at the second step. The torque wrench would not overcome the friction of the stationary bolt and would hit 38Nm before the bolt even moves. As a rule of thumb incremental changes should be no less than 5Nm and if possible should be greater.

 

Lubrication
For highly torqued fasteners often times the service manual will specify that the threads of the fastener must be lubricated. The lubricant can be as simple as fresh engine oil or a specifically formulated thread lubricant product.

 

Posted Image

 

Adhering to any lubrication guidelines is of utmost importance. Since we most commonly measure torque to determine whether a bolt has been tightened/preloaded enough any change in the amount of force required to turn the bolt will influence the resulting bolt preload for a given torque value. The force required to turn a bolt is partially dependent on the amount of friction in the joint. If we had two identical fasteners where one was lubricated and the other was not, and we set the torque wrench to the same value for each, then both were tightened, the resulting bolt preload would be different between the two. Due to the reduced friction in the lubricated joint the bolt would stretch more and the preload in the joint would be higher at the specified torque wrench setting than the unlubricated joint. Depending on the criticality of the joint this can be a really big deal! It also shows why in some applications (think two piece conrods) directly measuring bolt stretch is a more accurate means of determining bolt preload.

 

I hope you enjoyed this quick summary of tightening techniques and their importance! If you have tips of your own you’d like to share or other pearls of wisdom please leave a comment.

 

For those of you interested in more engine building knowledge check out my book, The Four Stroke Dirt Bike Engine Building Handbook. You’ll find more detailed and comprehensive info on engine building there. Simply follow the links below. Thanks for reading and have a great week!

 

-Paul

 

Posted Image

 

The Four Stroke Dirt Bike Engine Building Handbook

 

Available on Amazon

Attached Thumbnails

  • Attached Image
  • Attached Image
  • Attached Image
  • Attached Image





Photo
Thump_Stump
Nov 08, 2016 02:25 PM

Pretty solid article.  However, i dont see anything about bolt cleanliness.  Bolts with old threadlocker, or which have had lube applied, the threads and the bolt should be cleaned off prior to reassembly.

    • Bryan Bosch, brraaapperdoodle and Paul Olesen like this
    • Like This
Photo
Paul Olesen
Nov 10, 2016 05:07 AM

Pretty solid article.  However, i dont see anything about bolt cleanliness.  Bolts with old threadlocker, or which have had lube applied, the threads and the bolt should be cleaned off prior to reassembly.

Thanks for your comment. I absolutely agree and am glad you brought this point up.

A very good article. I would like to reinforce two comments and add two.

1. The connecting rod bolt reference is an excellent one.There is a SIGNIFICANT difference between how tight a bolt is when tightened by a torque wrench, to torque spec, and tightening by measuring bolt stretch. I found that out through building a small block Chevy engine and comparing the ARP bolt stretch to the ARP bolt torque specs. It was so significant that I phoned ARP. All they would say was "use the bolt stretch spec". It actually made me question the true efficacy of any bolt torque specs.

2. Heed the comments about lubricating and cleaning the threads in Paul's advice. If the manufacturer doesn't say to lubricate the threads, don't do it. It makes a serious difference and the bolt will be too tight if you use oil when the manufacturer's spec is for a dry torque. Some manufacturers even state what kind of lubricant to use as it actually makes a difference in the torque result. All manufacturers expect the threads to be as clean as new.

2. It cannot be stressed enough how important it is to get a good torque wrench. The cheap ones are virtually useless and I would suggest a person could come just as close by feel. They can be that inaccurate.

3. If you don't have the proper tightening sequence on a large item, such as a side case, then tighten from the center out.

Thanks for a great article Paul.

    • Bryan Bosch and RailwayRog like this
    • Like This

Great stuff as always Paul.

Photo
Paul Olesen
Nov 16, 2016 04:52 AM

A very good article. I would like to reinforce two comments and add two.

1. The connecting rod bolt reference is an excellent one.There is a SIGNIFICANT difference between how tight a bolt is when tightened by a torque wrench, to torque spec, and tightening by measuring bolt stretch. I found that out through building a small block Chevy engine and comparing the ARP bolt stretch to the ARP bolt torque specs. It was so significant that I phoned ARP. All they would say was "use the bolt stretch spec". It actually made me question the true efficacy of any bolt torque specs.

2. Heed the comments about lubricating and cleaning the threads in Paul's advice. If the manufacturer doesn't say to lubricate the threads, don't do it. It makes a serious difference and the bolt will be too tight if you use oil when the manufacturer's spec is for a dry torque. Some manufacturers even state what kind of lubricant to use as it actually makes a difference in the torque result. All manufacturers expect the threads to be as clean as new.

2. It cannot be stressed enough how important it is to get a good torque wrench. The cheap ones are virtually useless and I would suggest a person could come just as close by feel. They can be that inaccurate.

3. If you don't have the proper tightening sequence on a large item, such as a side case, then tighten from the center out.

Thanks for a great article Paul.

Thanks for your comments GDT!

Photo
Paul Olesen
Nov 16, 2016 04:52 AM

Great stuff as always Paul.

Thanks, glad you liked it.

Good stuff.  

 

It's also worth mentioning to learn, if possible, whether or not a particular bolt can be reused.  There are applications, typically joints requiring a particular clamping force or where heat cycles cause movement, where bolts should not be reused.  If those one time use bolts are re-installed they will not achieve or maintain the designed clamping force even though the specified torque spec is met.

Photo
Thump_Stump
Nov 21, 2016 11:59 AM

Good stuff.  

 

It's also worth mentioning to learn, if possible, whether or not a particular bolt can be reused.  There are applications, typically joints requiring a particular clamping force or where heat cycles cause movement, where bolts should not be reused.  If those one time use bolts are re-installed they will not achieve or maintain the designed clamping force even though the specified torque spec is met.

 

As long as it doesnt get deformed during installation/use, it can be reused until deformation occurs or deemed not worth reusing.  Such as a bolt thats almost stripped or very rusty, lock nuts, Torque to yield, spring washers, and anything that gets peened or staked would be examples of bolts/nuts needing replaced.  Or for some reason the last time I did my oil the short bolt for the filter cap stretched almost twice its length.  That would be a great time to replace it, even though its not a "must replace" part.  Lol.  But at the end of the day, for that I still say "Refer to the shop manual for best advice" .  If it says "replace" - I would.

About Paul Olesen

You can learn more about me HERE.

 

Posted Image
Follow me on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/DIYMotoFix

 

Posted Image

 

Visit my website by clicking the logo above!

Search My Blog

Recent Comments

 
x

Join Our Community!

Even if you don't want to post, registered members get access to tools that make finding & following the good stuff easier.

The views and opinions expressed on this page are strictly those of the author, and have not been reviewed or approved by ThumperTalk.